How Disability Law Could Guide Military Reform: A Blueprint for Justice and Inclusion
- Kirk Carlson
- Jun 2
- 3 min read

In recent years, the conversation around disability rights has expanded beyond civilian spaces to challenge the long-standing practices within the U.S. military. Thousands of service members are discharged every year due to injuries—many of them sustained during training, not combat—and find themselves stripped of their careers, benefits, and dignity. But what if the military were held to the same legal standards as civilian employers? What if federal disability laws like the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) informed military reform?
This isn’t just a hypothetical. It’s a necessary blueprint for change.
🔍 The Legal Gap Between Civilian and Military Systems
In the civilian world, federal law prohibits employers from terminating employees solely due to a medical condition without first exploring reasonable accommodations or reassignment to a different role. Under the ADA and the Rehabilitation Act, employers must engage in an “interactive process” to determine whether a disabled employee can continue working in a modified capacity.
In contrast, the military routinely discharges service members who are deemed “non-deployable,” even if they could serve effectively in other roles. Unlike the civilian sector, the military is exempt from the ADA, creating a systemic blind spot that disproportionately harms injured troops—especially those injured before deployment.
⚖️ Why Disability Law Principles Still Matter
Even if the ADA doesn’t legally bind the Department of Defense, its principles provide a clear and ethical standard:
Reasonable Accommodation: If a service member can no longer perform combat duties but can work as a dispatcher, analyst, instructor, or in administration, why not allow them to continue serving?
Reassignment as a Solution: Civilian employers are required to reassign qualified employees to vacant positions they can perform. The military already has thousands of MOS (military occupational specialties)—many of which are non-combat. Yet, reassignment is rarely considered.
Due Process & Transparency: Civilian employees must be given clear explanations and opportunities to appeal decisions affecting their employment. Injured service members often receive a discharge notice with little explanation and limited recourse.
💥 The Human Cost of Inaction
When the military discharges a service member due to a training injury without accommodation, the consequences are severe:
Loss of career and retirement path
Limited or no access to the GI Bill or VA healthcare
Long-term mental health struggles, including depression and survivor’s guilt
Economic hardship due to underemployment or unemployability
Many of these veterans never even deployed—so they’re often overlooked, misunderstood, or left out of the broader conversation around veterans’ rights.
🧭 A Roadmap for Military Reform
Applying the spirit of disability law to military reform could radically improve outcomes for service members and strengthen the armed forces. Key reforms might include:
Establishing a Reasonable Accommodation Office within each service branch
Creating a formal career reassignment process for injured personnel
Amending military policy to consider non-deployable status as a transition opportunity, not a dead end
Expanding VA eligibility for those discharged with service-connected conditions—even before deployment
Holding commanders and review boards to accountability standards consistent with civilian disability practices
🫡 Because Readiness Shouldn’t Mean Disposability
Service members are trained to give everything for their country. But when they are injured in the line of duty—especially during training—they should not be cast aside. Disability law offers a fairer, more compassionate model for how we treat those who serve.
We owe it to our veterans to bridge the gap between law and loyalty. Let disability rights guide military reform—not just because it’s legally sound, but because it’s morally right.
Support the #ReasonableRanks Campaign
Sign the petition. Share your story. Advocate for change.
Comments