What the ADA, VA, and DoD Miss About Injured Trainees
- Kirk Carlson
- Jun 25
- 3 min read

🔎 How Systemic Gaps Leave Thousands Behind
In the shadow of America’s most powerful laws and agencies—the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), and the Department of Defense (DoD)—there exists a troubling blind spot: injured military trainees.
While these systems were created to protect, support, and compensate our nation’s service members, many young Americans who are injured during basic training or initial entry never fully qualify for the protections they assumed would cover them. As a result, thousands fall through the cracks of our federal protections—denied care, denied status, and denied dignity.
⸻
⚖️ The ADA’s Miss: A Civilian Standard in a Military World
The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) was landmark legislation that transformed civilian life for people with disabilities by mandating reasonable accommodations and protecting against discrimination. But here’s the problem: the ADA does not apply to active-duty military service.
What this means in practice is that an individual injured on day one of boot camp—before ever deploying, before ever being classified as a “veteran”—can be discharged without the protections or accommodations that would be required in a civilian job.
💬 “If you get injured at Target, you’re protected by the ADA. If you get injured at boot camp, you’re expendable.”
⸻
🪖 The DoD’s Dilemma: Deployment or Discharge
The Department of Defense prioritizes deployability as the gold standard of readiness. But in doing so, it often disregards the humanity and future of those who fall short due to injury—especially during training.
Each year, the military quietly separates thousands of trainees who never make it past basic training due to musculoskeletal injuries, mental health conditions, or medical complications. These injuries are often service-related, yet the individuals are treated as if they never truly served.
No reassignment.
No retraining.
No transitional support.
⸻
🧾 The VA’s Limitation: The Line of Duty Hurdle
The VA provides compensation and care for veterans with service-connected conditions. But injured trainees often fail to meet the criteria because:
• They were never deployed
• Their discharge wasn’t “honorable enough”
• Their injuries were not officially recorded as “in the line of duty”
This creates a tragic loophole where those most vulnerable—the youngest, newest recruits—are denied benefits and acknowledgment for injuries sustained during mandatory service training.
🛑 A fractured leg in basic training might leave you ineligible for VA benefits—while a similar injury during deployment receives full coverage.
⸻
📉 Who’s Getting Left Behind?
The data is scarce because it’s rarely tracked. But anecdotal evidence and veteran advocates report disproportionate discharges among:
• Women, particularly after pregnancy complications or injuries during physical training
• Recruits of color, who face higher rates of early discharge and mischaracterized mental health evaluations
• LGBTQ+ individuals, who are more likely to report harassment and denied accommodations
• Working-class enlistees, who join the military as a last hope—and are discarded without support
⸻
✊ What #ReasonableRanks Is Calling For
The #ReasonableRanks campaign is advocating for three core reforms:
1. Reassignment Pathways: Injured but capable individuals should be reassigned to admin, instructional, or stateside roles—not cast out.
2. Recognition for Trainees: Time spent in uniform—even in training—should count toward benefits when the injury was clearly sustained during service.
3. Oversight and Reform: The DoD and VA must track, report, and reform discharge practices that unfairly exclude trainees from support systems.
⸻
🔚 Final Thoughts: A Forgotten Fight for Justice
When a recruit steps onto the yellow footprints of boot camp, they’ve committed to serve. But if they’re injured before they “count,” the government too often abandons them.
The ADA doesn’t protect them.
The DoD doesn’t retain them.
The VA doesn’t compensate them.
This must change.
Injured trainees deserve dignity, recognition, and the same support promised to every service member.
📌 Take action today:
👉 Sign the petition: https://chng.it/5yXYvkBtMR
👉 Learn more: www.covenantofcourage.com/reasonableranks-action
⸻
Because service starts the day you swear in—not the day you deploy. Create an image for this article





Comments