Combat vs. Non-Combat Veterans: Understanding VA Disability Ratings
The discussion around VA disability ratings often sparks debates, especially when comparing combat veterans and non-combat veterans. Some misconceptions and stigmas persist, particularly the belief that combat veterans inherently deserve higher ratings or benefits compared to non-combat veterans. Let’s break down the facts and clarify the process for achieving service connection and receiving VA disability benefits.
The Big Three: The Foundation for VA Disability Claims
Every VA disability claim hinges on three key elements, commonly referred to as "The Big Three":
In-Service Event: A specific event, injury, or illness that occurred during military service.
Current Diagnosis: A medical condition diagnosed by a healthcare professional.
Nexus: A clear connection between the in-service event and the current diagnosis.
Combat service is not a requirement for establishing service connection. While combat experiences can provide strong evidence for certain claims (like PTSD), they are not a standalone criterion. Veterans who meet the Big Three requirements—regardless of combat status—are eligible for service connection and compensation.
Debunking the Stigma
A prevalent misconception is that combat veterans’ service is more “valid” or deserving of benefits than that of non-combat veterans. This belief is often perpetuated online, where some combat veterans may assert that non-combat veterans don’t deserve the same level of recognition or benefits. However, this is simply not true.
Veterans do not choose their deployments or assignments. A Marine Infantryman who spends nine months on a Marine Expeditionary Unit (MEU) deployment is no less deserving than one deployed to a combat zone. Both signed the same commitment and served honorably, and both are entitled to the same benefits if they meet the criteria.
Combat Service and PTSD Claims
Combat experience can provide solid evidence for conditions like PTSD. Awards such as the Combat Infantry Badge (CIB), Combat Action Badge (CAB), or Combat Action Ribbon (CAR) often serve as strong supporting evidence. However, these are not guarantees of service connection.
PTSD claims still require:
A verified stressor (e.g., a combat event),
A current PTSD diagnosis, and
A nexus between the stressor and the diagnosis.
Not every individual who experiences combat develops PTSD, just as not every PTSD diagnosis stems from combat. Claims must always be evidence-based.
Access to Information: The Real “Loophole”
The VA disability system does not have loopholes in the traditional sense. However, access to information often plays a significant role in whether veterans successfully file claims. Many veterans are simply unaware of their eligibility or the process of submitting evidence-based claims.
For instance, secondary claims—conditions that result from service-connected conditions—are frequently overlooked. A common example is hypertension rated at 0% due to medication. If the medication causes urinary frequency, the veteran could file a secondary claim for that condition, which might qualify for a 10%, 20%, or even 40% rating. Knowledge about these secondary claims is crucial.
Veterans who educate themselves about the claims process are better positioned to file comprehensive, evidence-backed claims. Resources like online tutorials, templates, and guides can be invaluable in navigating the system.
Moving Beyond Misconceptions
Veterans, whether they served in combat or not, deserve respect and recognition for their service. The VA disability system is not about ranking service experiences; it’s about compensating veterans for service-connected conditions.
The key takeaway is this: Combat service is not a prerequisite for receiving VA benefits. The only criteria are the Big Three—In-Service Event, Current Diagnosis, and Nexus.
Resources for Veterans
To help veterans navigate the claims process, countless resources are available online. These include templates for filing claims, detailed guides on secondary conditions, and curated playlists explaining how to maximize your VA claim. One such resource is the "What Veterans Need to Know" playlist, which consolidates essential information into 14 comprehensive videos.
With the internet providing unprecedented access to information, veterans now have the tools to take control of their claims process. Knowledge, combined with action, is the most effective way to achieve service connection and receive the compensation you deserve.
Final Thoughts
Combat and non-combat veterans alike bring unique experiences and sacrifices to their service. The VA disability system does not prioritize one over the other—it evaluates claims based on evidence and the Big Three criteria.
If you’re a veteran, the best thing you can do is educate yourself, gather your evidence, and submit a well-supported claim. Whether your service took you to combat zones or not, you are entitled to the benefits you’ve earned. Let’s move beyond comparisons and focus on ensuring every veteran has access to the support they deserve.
Comments