Reassignment Is Not a Weakness—It’s a Win A #ReasonableRanks Campaign Article | Covenant of Courage
- Kirk Carlson
- Jun 16
- 2 min read

When a service member joins the military, they take an oath to serve with honor, courage, and commitment. But what happens when an injury, illness, or unforeseen hardship makes it impossible for them to continue in their original role? For many, the answer is a quiet discharge, often during training, with little recognition and few long-term options.
That’s where the #ReasonableRanks campaign comes in.
We believe it’s time to change the narrative: Reassignment is not a sign of weakness—it’s a win. It’s a recognition that a person’s value doesn’t disappear the moment their body is injured or their medical status changes. Reassignment is a chance to redirect talent, experience, and loyalty into a meaningful path of continued service.
Reassignment Reflects Strength, Not Surrender
Some of the most resilient people in our armed forces are those who’ve faced adversity and adapted. Reassignment gives these individuals the opportunity to:
Continue serving in administrative, instructional, support, or technical capacities.
Mentor the next generation of military, police, or fire cadets.
Preserve their military identity and career progress rather than being cast aside.
This is not charity—it’s strategy. Our nation is stronger when it values people for their whole self, not just their physical capacity.
The Current Problem
Right now, the Department of Defense has limited options for non-deployable or medically disqualified service members—especially those discharged during initial training. Most are let go without ceremony, often without full benefits, and with little transition support.
It’s a loss—for them, and for all of us.
A Smarter Way Forward
The #ReasonableRanks campaign is advocating for a smarter approach. We are calling on the DoD and lawmakers to:
Establish a reassignment pathway for injured trainees and non-deployable service members.
Honor their service with proper recognition and a continued role when possible.
Invest in human capital by offering alternative career tracks, training, and community reintegration support.
Stories That Inspire
We’ve heard from veterans who were discharged due to injury but went on to serve their communities in other ways—mentoring youth, leading in public safety, or supporting fellow veterans. These are success stories that never would’ve happened if they had been labeled “unfit” and forgotten.
Let’s Build a Culture of Purpose, Not Punishment
We must move away from an outdated system that punishes injury with separation. Instead, let’s build a culture that celebrates adaptability, resilience, and continued contribution. Reassignment isn’t a consolation prize—it’s a mission shift.
Because service doesn’t end at discharge, and value doesn’t end with a medical note.
📢 Join the Movement
✍️ Sign the petition at www.ReasonableRanks.org
💬 Share your story.
📣 Spread the word.
Reassignment is not weakness. It’s a win—for the veteran, for the force, and for our future.
Comments