The Case for Reassignment: Building a More Compassionate Military
- Kirk Carlson
- Jul 14
- 3 min read

By Covenant of Courage | #ReasonableRanks Campaign
For generations, the U.S. military has operated on a foundation of strength, readiness, and cohesion. These principles remain essential. But as our armed forces evolve to meet 21st-century challenges, so too must our policies reflect a more humane, just, and inclusive approach to personnel management—especially for those injured in service.
At the heart of this evolution is a simple question:
Why discharge a service member who is still willing and able to serve in a different capacity?
This is the moral and strategic case for reassignment.
🩼 Discharge Isn’t Always the Right Answer
Each year, thousands of service members are medically discharged due to injuries, illnesses, or mental health conditions incurred during active duty. While some separations are necessary, many involve troops who are:
Still capable of performing non-combat or administrative duties
Desiring to serve and contribute to their unit’s mission
Experiencing mental, emotional, or financial hardship due to forced separation
Instead of offering a pathway to reassignment, these individuals are often shown the door. Their experience, loyalty, and training are discarded—despite years of honorable service.
“I was injured, not broken. I could still serve. But the system wouldn’t let me.”
— Testimony from a #ReasonableRanks supporter and former Army mechanic
🎖️ Reassignment: A Policy That Reflects Our Values
Reassignment would allow injured or limited-duty service members to transfer into non-deployable billets where their skills and commitment can continue to benefit the military. These positions could include:
Training support and logistics
Cybersecurity, intelligence, and technology roles
Medical admin and patient advocacy
Peer mentorship or transition counseling
Community engagement and public affairs
By expanding reassignment pathways, the military would demonstrate its commitment to people over paperwork—a shift from viewing service members as expendable to treating them as whole human beings with purpose beyond the battlefield.
💡 It’s Not Just Ethical—It’s Smart Strategy
The argument for reassignment isn’t only about compassion—it’s about mission success. Here’s why:
✅ Retention of Experience: Injured service members carry institutional knowledge, cultural fluency, and leadership skills that are difficult to replace.
✅ Cost Efficiency: It costs millions to recruit and train new troops. Reassigning capable personnel preserves talent and reduces turnover.
✅ Boosted Morale: When troops see that their service matters—regardless of injury—they are more likely to trust leadership and maintain high morale.
✅ Stronger Civil-Military Bridges: By incorporating wounded warriors into public affairs, disaster response, and mentorship programs, the military strengthens its connection with communities and future recruits.
⚖️ The Human Toll of Inflexible Systems
Too often, medically discharged veterans face:
Denied VA benefits due to lack of understanding or documentation
Isolation, unemployment, and PTSD from abrupt transition
Shame from feeling “discarded” despite their service
Homelessness or even suicide from system abandonment
Reassignment would provide continuity of identity, purpose, and support during recovery—something our warriors deserve.
🗳️ What #ReasonableRanks Is Fighting For
The #ReasonableRanks campaign is calling on Congress, the Department of Defense, and the military services to:
Establish reassignment as a mandatory alternative to discharge when feasible
Expand roles and MOS categories for limited-duty personnel
Protect rank and benefits for reassigned service members
Provide legal representation during the medical evaluation and separation process
Track outcomes for reassigned vs. discharged personnel to ensure policy success
We believe in a military that rewards resilience—not just readiness. That honors sacrifice—not just speed. That finds new roles for warriors instead of throwing them away.
✍️ Join the Mission
If you believe in building a stronger, smarter, and more compassionate military, stand with us.
📜 Sign the petition: https://chng.it/5yXYvkBtMR
📧 Contact us: support@reasonableranks.org
🌐 Learn more: www.covenantofcourage.com
The uniform may come off—but the mission never ends. Let’s build a military that honors that truth.
Comments